451 smart fortwo

I know the smart received very good crash safety ratings. However, did they test the Cabriolet? I wonder if it is as safe as the Passion/Pure, as they had to cut into the tridion in order to make it a convertible. The question came to my mind after the story on a smart forum about a smart owner whose car rolled 3 times after being hit at 70 mph on the freeway, and he opened the door and walked away. Would the Cabriolet perform as well?

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Probably... crosses fingers

link to cab tridion pic

Reply to This

In a rollover? No, of course not. You have less protection. Wear a helmet.

Reply to This

Disagree - you might lose the hair off your scalp if the top is down, but we (cabrio owners) have the obvious roll bar in back, AND another rollbar around the windshield. I know this is an ancient thread, but I wanted to post this pic for anyone who might search for such info in the future. Note the yellow roll bar in the cut out of the windshield surround. Since the seat belt will clinch you in a death grip, it should keep you from dropping even while upside down, and at 6' tall my head is not as high as the roll bars, so I felt much better when a friend pointed me towards this pic on SCOA. (Thanks BB!)

Reply to This

Yeah? What if you roll over on a fire hydrant?

Reply to This

Dude, seriously?

Reply to This

No. Seriously, I'd think you would be better protected in a Smart convertible than in most cars.

Reply to This

May 29th my wife and I were in a 2000 Jaguar XK8 and as I was passing a lady and a truck in front of her she decided to pass the truck too but without looking into her outside mirror. I was going no faster than 40 mph. I moved to the left and my left rear tire caught the soft shoulder and over-steer to the right. I corrected and the car started to go straight then over-steer to the left and into a ditch we went. We flipped back over front then rolled 3 times.

Where that yellow bar is is the "A" pillar. That was fine, but where that cross member is from driver's side to passenger's side was crushed down causing an 8" long, 1" wide non-ink tattoo in my scalp.

I too have a Carbio and I've thought about what would happen in the same accident. I hope that cross member is as strong as that reinforced "A" pillar in the smart. The roll bar is fine, but in my case, the rear part of the roof was okay, just the rear window shattered.

The rear roll bar will help to keep the whole car from coming down on your and I hope the cross member above the windshield is as strongs as the "A" piller and doen't collaps down towards the driver as it did in the Jaguar.

Reply to This

RSS

Members

  • Kerry Lee Dezall
  • argiros
  • Neill 'Chip' Reardon
  • lillian
  • adrain taylor

Latest Activity on 451s

Got it - will do. Thanks Ian
5 hours ago
Your best bet is to either remove the old one and take it to a battery centre; or look at it and note the amp hour rating, width, depth and height and terminal postion... then go to either a smart service centre or a good battery centre. 2005 smart…
13 hours ago
adrain taylor added a discussion
Can anyone tell me what battery I need to replace my old one?
17 hours ago
My Silver '06 FourTwo photos to come soon.
on Friday
Alan Shoemaker added 7 photos to the album 'Some of my car history'
on Friday
I have almost 35,000 on my 2008. I go pretty much by the owners service manual. Went to the dealer one time 2 hrs from home to reset the maintenance light. Probably around 20,000. Cost because I didn't want the service. Light is on again but goes of…
on Thursday
Michael Everett added 2 photos
on Thursday
I agree... Any software refinement should be FREE...
on Thursday

smartCar on Facebook/Twitter

facebook.com/smartCartwitter.com/smartCarRSS

smart Photos  |  smart Videos  |  smart Forum  |  smart Blogs  |  smart Events  |  smart Car Clubs

Badges  |  Bug Report  |  Terms of Service

Sign in to chat!
Disclaimer: This is a user generated "Web 2.0" community, smart GmbH, smart USA and smart Canada are not responsible for the maintenance or creation of this page.
All brand names and/or trademarks used are for reference only and are the property of their respective holders.